HOME Masonic Etiquette TrestleBoard Cub Scout Pack 818 Masonic Links Questions Masonry Explained FACTS Hall Rentals MAP GA GROUPS Secretary's Desk Past Masters Masonic Videos Clip Art Masonic Essays Masonic Humor Sign our Guestbook Contact Us Calendar Dues and Donations Shrine Club

Here you will find a small collection of essays dealing with Freemasonry. Please give us some feedback and let us know what you think about these

Masonic Myths - Reality Check - The Masonic Blue Slipper - Is Masonry Education - It is the Mason.... - Debating Anti-Masons - Principles, Morals, Ethics

 

Debating Anti-Masons

Is debate possible with someone who is so inflexible, whose ideas are so foreign, and who appears to be totally wrong?

Over the years, Masons have tried to engage in debates with those who believe Masonry is satanic, part of some huge conspiracy, or want to gain notoriety. The results are often less than satisfactory and the Mason may well come away feeling beaten -- not because his facts were wrong or his presentation weak but because he simply wasn't prepared for the range of seemingly ridiculous claims.

 

Author Deborah Lipstadt writing in "Denying The Holocaust" notes that she steadfastly refuses to share the forum (of whatever type: television program, radio talk show, college debate, whatever) with the 'Holocaust Deniers' because the existence of the Holocaust was simply not a matter of debate. She states that to appear with them would "...give them a legitimacy and stature that they in no way deserve. It would elevate their antisemitic ideology - which is what Holocaust denial is - to the level of responsible historiography - which it is not."

The same holds true for the anti-Masonic debate. There can be no argument that

  • Masonry is not a religion
  • Masonry does not seek world domination
  • Masonry is not a tool of Satan

yet we often feel the need to debate with those who would espouse those lies!

And Masons in these situations are always at a disadvantage. They'll be forthright and direct while their opponent will be practiced and smooth. The Mason will be a 'virgin' in this type of endeavor; his antagonist will have practiced this type of thing many, many times before. Whether it's 'witnessing' to Mormons or preaching the New World Order conspiracy, the Mason will consistently find himself at a disadvantage.

Instead of debating, this site encourages the following:

  • Constant learning about Masonry and its principles
  • Behavior in one's life so as to be above reproach
  • Not allowing a the lies of anti-Masons to go unchallenged - because the lie repeated often enough can become for some, the truth!